Quick verdict: CBSH vs PB in 2026

Alert Invest’s analysis indicates that Prosperity Bancshares, Inc. (PB) holds a significant overall edge over Commerce Bancshares, Inc. (CBSH) in our current 2026 comparison, excelling in profitability and offering a more attractive valuation. CBSH stands out as the growth leader with positive revenue momentum and offers a higher potential price target upside, while PB takes the lead in value metrics, demonstrating more attractive pricing relative to its book and a substantial DCF upside. PB also exhibits superior profitability through higher net and EBITDA margins and is the clear analyst favorite based on its higher percentage of ‘Buy’ ratings. This is not investment advice.

CBSH vs PB: key metrics side by side

Full side-by-side comparison of CBSH and PB across valuation, profitability, growth and analyst sentiment. Data updated 2026-05-03.

CBSH vs PB valuation comparison

When assessing the CBSH vs PB valuation, both banks trade at relatively similar price-to-earnings (P/E) multiples. Commerce Bancshares, Inc. (CBSH) has a P/E ratio of 13.17x, slightly higher than Prosperity Bancshares, Inc.’s (PB) P/E of 13.09x. This suggests that based purely on current earnings, PB is marginally cheaper. However, the picture changes significantly when we look at the price-to-book (P/B) ratio, a crucial metric for financial institutions. CBSH trades at a P/B of 1.76x, indicating it’s priced above its book value, while PB boasts a much lower P/B of 0.84x. This makes PB appear considerably more undervalued relative to its assets and equity.

Furthermore, the discounted cash flow (DCF) analysis reveals a substantial difference in implied upside, which is a key component of the CBSH vs PB valuation. CBSH’s DCF suggests an upside of +10.3% from its current price of $52.03, reaching an intrinsic value of $57.41. In stark contrast, PB’s DCF points to a remarkable upside of +43.5% from its current price of $69.33, implying an intrinsic value of $99.46. This robust DCF valuation for PB strongly suggests it is the cheaper stock with significantly greater potential for appreciation based on its future cash flows. Therefore, for investors prioritizing a strong value proposition, PB appears to have a distinct advantage in the CBSH vs PB valuation landscape.

CBSH vs PB growth comparison

Examining the CBSH vs PB growth comparison for 2026, Commerce Bancshares, Inc. (CBSH) demonstrates a positive revenue growth trajectory, reporting a year-over-year growth of +2.2% with total revenue of $2.14 billion. This indicates a healthy, albeit modest, expansion in its operations. This positive momentum suggests that CBSH is successfully growing its customer base and financial activities, which is a crucial factor for long-term equity performance. The larger revenue base also positions CBSH as a more established entity in terms of scale.

In contrast, Prosperity Bancshares, Inc. (PB) experienced a slight contraction in its top-line, with revenue growth recorded at -0.2% on total revenue of $1.74 billion. This negative growth indicates a slight decrease in its revenue generation compared to the previous year. While profitability margins are strong for PB, a contracting revenue base can be a concern for growth-focused investors. For those specifically seeking companies with expanding market presence and increasing sales, CBSH’s positive revenue growth rate positions it as the stronger contender in this CBSH vs PB growth comparison. The market will be watching to see if PB can reverse its revenue trend in the coming periods, while CBSH aims to accelerate its current growth pace.

CBSH vs PB profitability

In the CBSH vs PB profitability analysis, Prosperity Bancshares, Inc. (PB) clearly demonstrates superior efficiency in converting revenue into profit. PB boasts a net margin of 31.2%, significantly higher than Commerce Bancshares, Inc.’s (CBSH) net margin of 26.11%. This substantial difference indicates that PB retains a larger portion of each dollar of revenue as net income, signaling more efficient cost management and stronger overall operational performance. This superior net margin contributes directly to a healthier bottom line for PB.

Similarly, PB’s EBITDA margin stands at an impressive 48.66%, substantially outperforming CBSH’s EBITDA margin of 36.25%. These figures underscore PB’s ability to generate more profit from its core operations before accounting for non-operating expenses, taxes, and depreciation. When considering cash generation, both companies show competitive free cash flow (FCF) yields. CBSH has an FCF yield of 7.46%, while PB’s FCF yield is marginally higher at 7.52%. This slight edge suggests that PB generates slightly more cash flow relative to its market capitalization, indicating a robust ability to fund operations, pay dividends, or reduce debt. Both companies reported ‘N/A%’ for Return on Equity (ROE), thus this metric cannot be used for direct comparison. Overall, for investors prioritizing strong profitability and efficient cash conversion, PB emerges as the more attractive option in this CBSH vs PB profitability assessment, demonstrating better command over its operational costs and a stronger bottom line.

Analyst ratings: CBSH vs PB

The analyst ratings for CBSH vs PB present an interesting divergence in sentiment. Commerce Bancshares, Inc. (CBSH) is covered by a panel of 15 analysts, but only 6.7% of them currently recommend a ‘Buy’ rating. The overarching consensus among these analysts leans towards ‘Hold’, suggesting a neutral outlook on the stock’s immediate future. Despite this more cautious stance, the analysts have collectively set a consensus price target of $58.5 for CBSH, which represents a potential upside of +12.4% from its current price of $52.03. This indicates that while there isn’t widespread enthusiasm, the limited ‘Buy’ recommendations and the overall target see a notable appreciation potential.

On the other hand, Prosperity Bancshares, Inc. (PB) enjoys significantly broader analyst coverage, with 33 analysts providing ratings, more than double that of CBSH. A much higher percentage, 42.4%, of these analysts recommend a ‘Buy’ for PB, indicating a stronger overall preference for the stock compared to CBSH, even though the overall consensus also remains a ‘Hold’. The consensus price target for PB is $73, offering a more modest upside of +5.3% from its current price of $69.33. Therefore, while CBSH currently offers a higher implied target price upside according to analysts, analysts in general show a considerably greater level of conviction and buying interest in PB based on the proportion of ‘Buy’ ratings in this CBSH vs PB analyst comparison.

Should I buy CBSH or PB stock in 2026?

When considering whether should I buy CBSH or PB stock in 2026, the optimal choice heavily depends on an investor’s specific objectives and risk tolerance. For growth-oriented investors, Commerce Bancshares, Inc. (CBSH) might be the more appealing option. With a positive revenue growth rate of +2.2% compared to PB’s -0.2%, CBSH demonstrates better top-line momentum, suggesting potential for continued business expansion and market share gains. This indicates that the company is currently expanding its operational footprint and revenue streams. However, it’s crucial to weigh this against other factors such as profitability and valuation. This is not investment advice.

For value investors, Prosperity Bancshares, Inc. (PB) presents a more compelling case when evaluating CBSH vs PB fundamentals and valuation. Its P/B ratio of 0.84x is significantly lower than CBSH’s 1.76x, indicating it is priced more attractively relative to its assets. Furthermore, PB’s discounted cash flow (DCF) analysis implies a substantial upside of +43.5%, far exceeding CBSH’s +10.3%. While both have similar P/E ratios, PB’s stronger profitability metrics, including higher net and EBITDA margins, further enhance its appeal from a value perspective, suggesting better operational efficiency and stronger underlying financial health. This is not investment advice.

Regarding income, neither CBSH nor PB stands out as a high-yield dividend stock, with both offering very low dividend yields. CBSH has a dividend yield of 0.02%, while PB offers a marginally higher yield of 0.03%. Therefore, for investors primarily focused on generating substantial income through dividends, neither stock is likely to be a primary choice based on these figures. Ultimately, the decision on should I buy CBSH or PB stock in 2026 requires a thorough examination of individual financial goals, recognizing PB’s edge in value and profitability versus CBSH’s current lead in revenue growth. This is not investment advice.

More CBSH and PB comparisons

CBSH full stock analysis · PB full stock analysis · All stock comparisons

FAQ: CBSH vs PB