Quick verdict: CACC vs HOMB in 2026

In this CACC vs HOMB stock comparison for 2026, Home Bancshares, Inc. (HOMB) appears to have an overall edge, leading on more comparable metrics, particularly in valuation and analyst sentiment. Credit Acceptance Corporation (CACC) demonstrates stronger revenue growth momentum and superior free cash flow generation, while HOMB stands out for its higher net and EBITDA margins and more attractive valuation multiples. Analysts currently lean towards HOMB for higher potential upside, though CACC shows significant intrinsic value according to discounted cash flow. Not investment advice.

CACC vs HOMB: key metrics side by side

Full side-by-side comparison of CACC and HOMB across valuation, profitability, growth and analyst sentiment. Data updated 2026-05-13.

CACC vs HOMB valuation comparison

When considering CACC vs HOMB valuation, Home Bancshares (HOMB) appears to offer a more attractive entry point based on traditional multiples. HOMB trades at a P/E ratio of 10.62x and a P/B ratio of 1.17x, which are both lower than CACC’s P/E of 12.38x and significantly lower P/B of 3.71x. Despite similar market capitalizations – CACC at $5.47 billion and HOMB at $5.19 billion – HOMB’s lower price-to-earnings and price-to-book ratios suggest it is valued more conservatively by the market.

However, a deeper look into the intrinsic value through discounted cash flow (DCF) analysis presents a different picture. CACC has a DCF valuation of $624.38, indicating a substantial +19.5% upside from its current price of $522.656. In contrast, HOMB’s DCF valuation of $21.08 suggests an -18.2% downside from its current price of $25.775, implying it may be overvalued based on its projected future cash flows. This dichotomy highlights that while HOMB is cheaper on current multiples, CACC’s long-term intrinsic value potential may be stronger according to this specific valuation model.

CACC vs HOMB growth comparison

In terms of revenue growth, Credit Acceptance Corporation (CACC) demonstrates significantly stronger momentum compared to Home Bancshares (HOMB). CACC reported a robust year-over-year revenue growth of +8.6%, indicating an expanding business and increasing market penetration in its specialized auto lending segment. This positive growth suggests the company is effectively navigating its operational environment and expanding its top line.

Conversely, Home Bancshares (HOMB) experienced a revenue decline of -5.3% year-over-year. This negative growth indicates challenges in expanding its revenue base, which might stem from competitive pressures, interest rate dynamics affecting loan demand, or other macroeconomic factors impacting the banking sector. While HOMB boasts a higher EBITDA margin of 44.84% compared to CACC’s 36.05%, CACC’s ability to grow its revenue base is a critical factor for investors focused on top-line expansion and market share gains, positioning it as the clear growth leader in this CACC vs HOMB comparison for 2026.

CACC vs HOMB profitability

When analyzing CACC vs HOMB profitability, Home Bancshares (HOMB) stands out with superior net margins. HOMB recorded an impressive net margin of 34.84%, significantly higher than CACC’s 19.61%. This indicates that HOMB is more efficient at converting its revenue into net income, reflecting stronger cost management or a business model with inherently higher profitability. Both companies have an N/A% for Return on Equity (ROE) in the provided data, which means we cannot use this metric for a direct comparison of shareholder return efficiency.

Despite HOMB’s higher net margin, CACC demonstrates a much stronger Free Cash Flow (FCF) yield of 19.25%, dwarfing HOMB’s FCF yield of 7.82%. A higher FCF yield indicates that CACC generates significantly more cash available to shareholders relative to its market capitalization. This suggests that while HOMB might be more profitable on paper (net margin), CACC is better at generating actual cash that can be used for debt reduction, share buybacks, or future investments. Therefore, for investors prioritizing cash generation, CACC generates more cash relative to its value.

Analyst ratings: CACC vs HOMB

Analyst sentiment clearly favors Home Bancshares (HOMB) over Credit Acceptance Corporation (CACC) as of May 13, 2026. Out of 19 analysts covering HOMB, a substantial 36.8% have a “Buy” rating on the stock, with the remaining maintaining a “Hold” consensus. This indicates a notable level of confidence in HOMB’s future performance among market professionals. The average analyst price target for HOMB is $32, which implies a significant +24.2% upside from its current price of $25.775.

In stark contrast, CACC’s analyst picture is less optimistic. Among 18 analysts, 0.0% have a “Buy” rating, with the consensus remaining a “Hold.” The average price target for CACC is $540, representing a modest +3.3% upside from its current price of $522.656. This substantial difference in both the percentage of “Buy” ratings and the implied price target upside suggests that analysts see much greater potential for capital appreciation in HOMB than in CACC.

Should I buy CACC or HOMB stock in 2026?

Deciding whether to buy CACC or HOMB stock in 2026 depends heavily on your investment priorities, considering their distinct financial profiles. For growth-oriented investors, Credit Acceptance Corporation (CACC) presents a compelling case with its +8.6% year-over-year revenue growth. This top-line expansion signals a business with strong operational momentum, potentially offering greater capital appreciation if this growth trajectory continues. HOMB, with its -5.3% revenue decline, does not align with a pure growth strategy, making CACC the preferred option for those seeking dynamic growth.

For value investors, the CACC vs HOMB fundamentals and valuation present a more nuanced choice. Home Bancshares (HOMB) appears cheaper on traditional valuation multiples, with a P/E ratio of 10.62x and a P/B ratio of 1.17x, both notably lower than CACC’s P/E of 12.38x and P/B of 3.71x. However, CACC’s discounted cash flow (DCF) analysis points to a substantial +19.5% upside, suggesting it might be intrinsically undervalued, whereas HOMB’s DCF indicates an -18.2% downside. This dichotomy means HOMB offers a lower entry multiple, while CACC might offer more long-term value potential based on future cash flows.

For investors prioritizing income, the choice is straightforward. Home Bancshares (HOMB) offers a modest dividend yield of 0.03%, providing at least some return to shareholders through dividends. Credit Acceptance Corporation (CACC), on the other hand, currently has a 0% dividend yield, making it unsuitable for income-focused portfolios. Therefore, if generating regular income from your investments is key, HOMB is the only option between the two. This is not investment advice; please conduct your own thorough research.

More CACC and HOMB comparisons

CACC full stock analysis · HOMB full stock analysis · All stock comparisons

FAQ: CACC vs HOMB