Quick verdict: BJ vs WMT in 2026

Walmart (WMT) holds a slight overall edge based on a majority of comparable metrics and strong analyst conviction, despite BJ’s compelling valuation and higher theoretical upside. While both companies show identical revenue growth, BJ stands out as the value leader and offers the most significant potential upside according to DCF and analyst price targets. WMT maintains its position as the margin leader and is the clear analyst favorite with a higher percentage of ‘Buy’ ratings. Not investment advice.

BJ vs WMT: key metrics side by side

Full side-by-side comparison of BJ and WMT across valuation, profitability, growth and analyst sentiment. Data updated 2026-05-07.

BJ vs WMT valuation comparison

When considering the BJ vs WMT valuation, BJ’s Wholesale Club appears significantly more attractive on several key metrics. BJ currently trades at a P/E ratio of 20.81x, which is less than half of Walmart’s P/E of 47.36x. Similarly, BJ’s price-to-book (P/B) ratio stands at 5.48x, far lower than WMT’s 10.41x. These figures suggest that BJ is valued more conservatively by the market compared to its much larger rival. Investors seeking a potentially undervalued stock in the consumer defensive sector might find BJ more appealing based on these traditional valuation multiples in 2026.

Beyond static multiples, the discounted cash flow (DCF) analysis presents a compelling argument for BJ. Our DCF model indicates a remarkable upside of +107.0% for BJ, suggesting its intrinsic value is considerably higher than its current share price of $92.45. In contrast, Walmart, despite its strong market position, shows a DCF upside of +13.9%. This substantial difference in theoretical upside highlights BJ’s potential for significant price appreciation, making it a standout in a detailed BJ vs WMT fundamentals and valuation assessment.

BJ vs WMT growth comparison

In terms of top-line expansion, the BJ vs WMT growth comparison reveals an interesting parity in their recent performance. Both BJ’s Wholesale Club and Walmart reported identical year-over-year revenue growth of +4.7%. While the percentage growth is the same, it’s crucial to acknowledge the vast difference in scale; BJ generated $21.46 billion in revenue, whereas Walmart’s revenue reached an astounding $713.16 billion. This means Walmart’s +4.7% growth represents a much larger absolute increase in sales, reflecting its dominant market presence.

However, when we look beyond just the historical revenue growth, BJ’s forward-looking metrics hint at stronger momentum or at least greater perceived undervaluation relative to its potential. The impressive DCF upside of +107.0% for BJ, coupled with a higher analyst price target upside of +13.2%, suggests that the market, or at least analysts, anticipate BJ closing the gap between its current price and intrinsic value more aggressively. For investors focused on future appreciation potential from current levels, BJ offers a more dramatic story than WMT’s more modest +13.9% DCF upside and +5.5% target upside.

BJ vs WMT profitability

When analyzing BJ vs WMT profitability, Walmart (WMT) generally demonstrates superior operational efficiency, securing an edge in several margin metrics. Walmart reported a net margin of 3.07%, slightly outperforming BJ’s 2.7%. This indicates that Walmart converts a larger portion of its revenue into net income. Furthermore, WMT’s EBITDA margin of 6.52% also surpasses BJ’s 5.21%, highlighting Walmart’s stronger performance at the operating level before accounting for depreciation and amortization. While the differences may seem incremental, they reflect Walmart’s scale and established operational advantages in a highly competitive retail landscape.

Despite Walmart’s advantage in net and EBITDA margins, BJ’s Wholesale Club takes the lead in free cash flow (FCF) generation relative to its market capitalization. BJ boasts a FCF yield of 2.81%, which is considerably higher than Walmart’s 1.44%. This suggests BJ is more efficient at converting its revenue into cash that can be used for debt reduction, dividends, or share buybacks, relative to its market size. Both companies currently report N/A% for Return on Equity (ROE) in the provided data. Moreover, Walmart exhibits a healthier balance sheet with a lower debt-to-equity ratio of 0.67x compared to BJ’s 1.19x, indicating WMT’s stronger financial stability.

Analyst ratings: BJ vs WMT

The analyst community shows a clear preference for Walmart (WMT) when comparing BJ vs WMT. Out of 64 analysts covering Walmart, a substantial 71.9% have issued a ‘Buy’ rating, leading to a strong consensus of ‘Buy’. The average price target for WMT stands at $137.22, offering a modest but positive upside of +5.5% from its current price of $130.08. This strong institutional endorsement reflects confidence in Walmart’s stability, market leadership, and consistent performance.

In contrast, BJ’s Wholesale Club receives a more mixed reaction from analysts. With 27 analysts providing coverage, 44.4% recommend a ‘Buy’ for BJ, resulting in an overall ‘Hold’ consensus. Despite the lower percentage of buy ratings, BJ’s average price target of $104.67 suggests a more significant potential upside of +13.2% from its current price of $92.45. This indicates that while fewer analysts are outright bullish on BJ, those who are see greater room for appreciation, particularly in the context of its more attractive valuation.

Should I buy BJ or WMT stock in 2026?

For growth-oriented investors asking, “should i buy bj or wmt stock 2026?”, the decision hinges on the type of growth you prioritize. While both companies reported an identical +4.7% revenue growth, BJ’s offers a compelling narrative through its significantly higher DCF upside of +107.0% and a more substantial analyst price target upside of +13.2%. This indicates a greater potential for capital appreciation if the company’s intrinsic value is realized by the market. Walmart, though stable, offers a more modest +13.9% DCF upside and +5.5% price target upside, suggesting a more mature growth profile.

Value investors will likely find BJ’s Wholesale Club more attractive for a “BJ vs WMT fundamentals and valuation” analysis. BJ trades at a P/E ratio of 20.81x and a P/B ratio of 5.48x, making it considerably cheaper than Walmart, which trades at a P/E of 47.36x and a P/B of 10.41x. These valuation metrics, coupled with BJ’s strong free cash flow yield of 2.81% (compared to WMT’s 1.44%), position BJ as a potentially undervalued asset with solid cash-generating capabilities relative to its market size.

For income-focused investors, neither BJ nor WMT is a high-yield dividend stock. BJ currently offers a 0% dividend yield, while Walmart provides a minimal 0.01% yield. Therefore, if a consistent and significant dividend income is your primary investment goal, both stocks might fall short. However, WMT’s slightly better profitability margins, lower debt-to-equity ratio (0.67x vs 1.19x), and vast scale might offer more long-term dividend stability or growth potential should the company decide to prioritize higher payouts in the future. This is not investment advice; always conduct your own thorough research.

More BJ and WMT comparisons

BJ full stock analysis · WMT full stock analysis · All stock comparisons

FAQ: BJ vs WMT